Skip to content
PoolBuff

Pool Heaters Compared: Gas, Heat Pump, Solar and Electric

By Robert Henry

Which heater suits which climate and use pattern, how to size one properly, and where the marketing numbers fall apart.

By Robert Henry

Pool service and repair, 15+ years

10 min read(last month)

I earn a commission if you buy through links here, at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How that works

The short answer

Gas heats fast in any weather and costs the most of the three to run. Heat pumps cost about half as much in DOE's city figures, and the ratio moves with your gas and electricity prices, but they heat slowly and lose output as the air cools, stopping to defrost around 50°F. Solar is nearly free to run and only works when the sun is out. Match the heater to how you actually use the pool.

10 min read
A gas heater and a heat pump installed side by side at a pool pad
Gas heats fast and costs more. A heat pump is the opposite of that.

The first question isn't which heater. It's how you plan to use the pool.

Somebody who wants the water warm on a whim next Saturday needs a completely different machine from somebody who wants 82°F from April to October. Get that backward and you'll be unhappy with a perfectly good heater.

Key takeaways

  • Choose on use pattern, not on price. Occasional weekend heat and season-long warmth are different problems.
  • Heater sizing, by DOE's formula: pool area × temperature rise × 12 gives the output needed in BTU an hour.
  • Heat pump output is quoted at 80°F air. Hayward and Pentair also rate theirs at 50°F, where it is roughly 60 to 70 percent of that.
  • Pentair, Raypak and Jandy allow salt pools on their standard copper gas heaters. All three exclude heat exchanger damage from unbalanced water.
  • DOE calls a cover the single most effective way to cut pool heating costs, and says it can save 50% to 70%.
GasHeat pumpMy defaultSolarElectric resistance
Running costHighAbout half of gas in DOE's tablesAlmost noneAbout five times a heat pump
Speed to heatFastSlowSlow, weather dependentSlow
Cold weatherHolds any temperature, says DOELoses output; stops to defrost around 50°FNeeds sunWorks, expensively
Best forOn-demand, spas, cold climatesSeason-long warmthCheap season extensionSmall pools and spas only

Gas

Burns natural gas or propane in a combustion chamber, transferring heat through an exchanger into the water.

Buy it if you want heat on demand, you have an attached spa, or you're in a climate where a heat pump won't cope. DOE calls gas heaters ideal for heating a pool quickly, and says that unlike a heat pump or solar, they can hold any temperature regardless of the weather. The Pentair MasterTemp 400 and Raypak 406A are two 400,000 BTU choices; the Raypak is actually rated at 399,000, and its page explains the dealer clause in its warranty. The MasterTemp's own page has the full parts list and the one spec that catches people out — every model has a minimum flow rate, 40 GPM on the 400, below which it will not fire at all. Hayward's Universal H-Series is the direct alternative, and the comparison is less obvious than price suggests: it asks only 30 GPM at the same size, and it puts a cupro-nickel heat exchanger in every model where Pentair charges for one and gives up two points of efficiency to fit it. The third is the Jandy JXi, which is the compact one and the only one of the three whose warranty is void entirely if you buy it online.

Sizing: DOE's formula is pool area × temperature rise × 12, for the heater's output in BTU an hour. The rise is the water temperature you want minus the average air temperature in the coldest month you swim. Take a 16×32 pool, which is 512 sq ft. Want it 20°F above that air? That's 512 × 20 × 12 = 122,880 BTU/hr of output, which a gas heater at 84% delivers from about 146,000 BTU of input.

DOE says the formula assumes the water rises 1°F to 1¼°F an hour against a 3½ mph wind at the surface. For 2°F an hour, it says to double it: about 245,800 BTU/hr of output, or about 293,000 of input on gas. Pentair's, Raypak's and Jandy's residential gas heaters run up to about 400,000.

At the bottom of that range, Pentair's condensing ETi 250 is worth knowing about, because the efficiency figure below is not the one it runs at: Pentair rates it 94% on natural gas and 96% on propane against the 84% a conventional heater manages. That changes the gas arithmetic materially. It also brings conditions — altitude limits that differ between natural gas and propane, and acidic condensate that has to be neutralized before it goes anywhere.

Run your own pool through the heater sizing calculator — it does the sizing rule and the heat-up time together, which matters because they come from different numbers. Size comes from surface area, and how long it takes comes from volume.

Watch for: propane. At the $2.55 a gallon in the callout above, it works out near $2.79 a therm before tax, a little under twice the 2025 natural gas average of about $1.48, for the same heat. And check the gas line before you buy. Pentair's MasterTemp manual sizes it by the heater and the distance from the meter: on natural gas a 1-inch line feeds the 175 for up to 125 feet but the 400 for only 20, and the 400 needs 1¼-inch to reach 100 feet. It also says to check that the meter can supply the heater and every other gas appliance on it. If you might change fuels later, Hayward's Universal HC Series ships set for natural gas with the propane mixer in the box, and a qualified service agency converts it on site.

Heat pump

Pulls heat out of the air and moves it into the water using a refrigeration cycle. It doesn't create heat, it relocates it, which is why it's so much cheaper per degree.

Buy it if you want the pool warm all season and you're somewhere with reasonably warm air. DOE says heat pumps work efficiently as long as the outside air stays above the 45°F to 50°F range, and lose efficiency the cooler it gets. The Hayward HeatPro 140k shows what that means on paper: Hayward's manual rates it at 138,000 BTU in 80°F air, where its product pages say 140,000, and at 82,000 in 50°F air. Jandy's VersaTemp manual says a heat pump won't heat a pool as fast as a large gas heater, and can take several days to bring a cold pool back up.

The catch that matters: output is quoted at 80°F air, 80% humidity and 80°F water. Hayward, Pentair and Jandy all print a second rating at 50°F air in their manuals, and on current models it is roughly 60 to 70 percent of the headline figure, at a COP of about 4. Around 50°F the coil also has to defrost, and heating stops while it does — about 15 minutes at a time on Pentair's UltraTemp, anything up to several hours by Hayward's manual.

If you want to heat in spring and fall, that is the weather you will be heating in. Size on the 50°F rating, not the headline number.

Watch for: they're physically large and they need air around them. Hayward's HeatPro manual asks for 12 inches at the sides, 24 to 36 at the service front and 72 inches above to any overhang; Pentair's UltraTemp asks for 24 inches at the front, 12 on the other sides and 5 feet above if it sits under an overhang. They make noise too, and the makers treat it as something to engineer down: Hayward's variable-speed HeatPro VS has a Silent Mode, and it gets its quiet by cutting output. And they need a big circuit: a 40 to 70 amp breaker on the models in the heat pump wiring guide, where a gas heater runs on a few amps. My pool heater picks cover the gas and heat pump models worth shortlisting, and the heater pages group every gas heater and heat pump with a page here.

Solar

Water pumped through panels on a roof. The sun does the work.

Buy it if you have suitable roof area, decent sun, and you want to extend the season rather than heat on demand.

Sizing: DOE says collector area should equal 50% to 100% of your pool's surface, more in cooler and cloudier places, and that a cover usually lets you use less. A 512 sq ft pool wants 256 to 512 sq ft of collector. The makers don't agree on the range. Heliocol's installation manual puts the best size at 75% to 100%, Enersol says about 50% to 75%, and California's energy code accepts 60% or more as the heating system for a new pool.

Watch for: it only works when the sun's out, so you can't plan around it. DOE says collectors can face up to 45° east or west of true south without losing much, and that replacing a conventional heater with solar may need a bigger pump, or a second, smaller one, to move water through the collectors.

Electric resistance

An immersion element. Simple, and expensive to run, because you're paying for every unit of heat directly with no multiplier. DOE's own comparison puts a pool that costs $1,000 a year to heat this way at $200 with a heat pump averaging a COP of 5, at the same electricity price. At EIA's 2025 averages, a therm of heat costs about $5.07 from an element, $1.80 from natural gas at 82% and $1.01 from a heat pump.

My rule: small spas and very small pools only, where the volume is small enough that the bill stays small.

Running two heaters

The comparison above reads as a single choice. Two heaters doing different jobs is the other answer worth pricing.

Solar plus a heat pump. Solar carries the sunny days for the cost of pumping, and the heat pump covers the cloudy week and the cooler months. California's energy code lists this pairing as one of the ways a new pool can meet its heating rules. Magen eco-Energy, which sells Heliocol in the US, says letting solar do most of the work means the heat pump can be smaller than one sized to heat the pool alone. That is a seller's claim, and DOE's formula is still the way to check what the smaller heat pump can hold on its own.

Gas plus a heat pump suits a pool with an attached spa. The heat pump holds the pool through the season, and the gas heater does the spa on demand. Lifting a 400-gallon spa from 60°F to 102°F takes about 140,000 BTU. A 400,000 BTU gas heater at 84% delivers that in about 25 minutes. The HeatPro 140 needs about an hour in 80°F air and closer to an hour and three-quarters in 50°F air, before any heat lost along the way.

Gas plus solar works where gas is the only practical option and the roof is available. The solar reduces how often the gas heater fires, and the gas it burns is the running cost.

Two heaters cost more to install. Whether that pays back depends on how much of the season the cheaper one carries, which is the arithmetic in the callout above, run once for each heater.

Plumbing. Raypak's manual says a solar system has to connect to the line ahead of its heater for the solar to act as the primary heat source, and the gas heater then won't fire while the solar holds the set point. Hayward's HeatPro manual plumbs its heat pump with three isolation valves, a check valve and two tees, and says to open the bypass and drain the heat pump when heating isn't needed for more than a week.

Sizing mistakes

Sizing below DOE's formula. The formula gives the output DOE says lifts the water 1°F to 1¼°F an hour against a 3½ mph wind in the coldest month you swim. A smaller heater heats more slowly than that. Raypak's warranty excludes performance problems from a heater sized wrong for the pool, too big or too small.

Forgetting minimum flow. Pentair and Hayward publish one for every gas heater size, and below it the heater won't fire: 40 GPM on the MasterTemp 400 and 30 on Hayward's H-Series 400. Pentair's troubleshooting chart checks it when a heater won't fire. Run your variable-speed pump too slow and the heater won't light, so schedule a higher-RPM block during heating hours.

The exchanger material, and the water. Cupronickel is the heavier-duty option: Pentair sells it as its HD MasterTemp at 82% against 84% for copper, and its catalog recommends HD for low pH, high flow or heavy use, and Hayward's Universal H-Series and its OmniX successor have it on every size. Pentair's condensing ETi 400 uses titanium. But the makers don't require it for salt. Pentair says its copper MasterTemp is designed for salt-system pools up to 5,000 ppm, and Raypak's and Jandy's manuals allow up to 4,500 ppm with no separate rule for copper. What all three warn about is the water: Pentair says low pH corrodes the copper tubes, Raypak says pH below 7.2 will severely damage the heat exchanger, and none of the three covers heat exchanger damage from unbalanced water. Pentair and Raypak also want a salt cell or chlorinator downstream of the heater.

Not planning for a cover. Whatever you buy, DOE says a cover can cut heating costs 50% to 70%. Budget for it in the same conversation, and see what each heater costs to run for DOE's figures.

Go deeperWhat each heater type actually costs to runDOE's season costs by city, and why the cover matters more than the heater. Go deeperHeating a hot tub is a different problemStandby loss, not heat-up, is what a spa actually costs you every month. Go deeperConverting to salt with a heater?The salt cell goes after the heater. What else the conversion involves, and costs.

Frequently asked questions

What size pool heater do I need?

DOE's formula is pool area × temperature rise × 12, which gives the heater's output in BTU an hour. The rise is the water temperature you want minus the average air temperature in the coldest month you swim. A 16×32 pool wanting a 20°F rise needs about 122,900 BTU an hour of output, which a gas heater at 84% delivers from about 146,000 BTU of input. DOE uses the same formula for heat pumps; size one on its output at your coldest swimming air, not the 80°F headline.

Which pool heater is cheapest to run?

Solar, since its running cost is the extra pump energy; DOE says it has very low annual operating costs. Between the active heaters, DOE's city tables put a heat pump at about half the cost of gas for the same pool, because it moves heat rather than making it. The gap depends on your rates: it is largest against propane and smallest where natural gas is cheap and electricity is not. Of those three, gas costs the most to run and heats the fastest. An electric resistance heater costs more still, about five times a heat pump for the same heat.

How long does a pool heater last?

DOE's Energy Saver pages say gas heaters typically last five or more years, heat pumps 10 or more and solar systems 10 to 20. Its 2023 pool heater rule averages 11.1 years for gas and electric heaters. Water chemistry shortens it. Pentair's MasterTemp manual says low pH corrodes the heater's copper tubes and can make them leak, and Raypak's says pH below 7.2 will severely damage the heat exchanger. Pentair, Raypak and Jandy all exclude heat exchanger damage from unbalanced or corrosive water from their warranties.

Can you use a heat pump in cold weather?

Up to a point. Output falls as the air cools: Hayward and Pentair rate their current heat pumps at roughly 60 to 70 percent of full output in 50°F air, and around that temperature the coil has to stop and defrost, sometimes for hours. If you want to heat in spring and fall, size on the 50°F rating in the manual rather than the headline figure quoted at 80°F.

Do I need a cover if I have a pool heater?

If you care about the bill, yes. DOE calls evaporation by far the largest source of energy loss from a pool, and calls covering a pool when it isn't in use the single most effective way to cut heating costs. It says a cover can save 50% to 70%.

Sources and further reading

Where this guide relied on standards, manufacturer documentation or published research rather than first-hand work.

Show the other 16 sources

Published September 5, 2026 · Last reviewed October 8, 2026. Spotted something out of date or wrong? Tell me and I will fix it — see the editorial policy.

About the author

Robert Henry

Pool service and repair, 15+ years

Over fifteen years in the pool business — service routes, equipment repair and warranty work, and the test counter.

  • 15+ years in the pool industry
  • Residential service routes
  • Equipment repair and warranty work
  • Pool retail and water testing
A pool heater with its service panel open showing the burner tray
RepairsTroubleshooting

Pool Heater Not Heating? Diagnose It in Order

Most heater faults are flow problems, gas supply problems or a dirty sensor. Here's the order to check things, and where to stop and call a pro.

6 minUpdated Oct 15, 2026