Skip to content
PoolBuff

Pool Heater Sizing and Heat-Up Calculator

Two questions get asked together and have different answers. Size comes from surface area, because that is where heat leaves. Heat-up time comes from volume, because that is the water you are warming.

The examples for size and fuel price change to suit it.

Length × width. Heat leaves through the surface.

sq ft

The water you are heating.

gal

°F
°F

The average air temperature in the coldest month you swim. DOE sizes a heater on the gap between this and the water you want. Leave it blank to skip the sizing.

°F

Gas heaters are rated by input. This calculator applies 84% efficiency to get delivered heat.

BTU/hr

Off your own bill. The examples are recent US averages from the EIA, and propane's is before tax.

$/therm

Two different numbers, and people conflate them. Volume decides how long a heat-up takes, because that is the water you are warming. Surface area decides what size heater you need, because that is where the heat leaves. A deep pool heats slowly; a wide one is expensive to hold warm.

Result

Enter your pool’s surface area

Only the numbers you enter are used. The ones marked “e.g.” are examples, and nothing is worked out from them.

Two questions get asked together and have different answers. Size comes from surface area, because that is where heat leaves. Heat-up time comes from volume, because that is the water you are warming.

Getting an accurate answer

  • Gas heaters are rated by input and deliver what their efficiency allows: 82% to 84% on the standard models from Pentair, Raypak and Jandy. Heat pumps are rated by output. Side by side, a 140,000 BTU heat pump reads as about a third of a 400,000 BTU gas heater; delivered, it is about two-fifths.
  • Every time here assumes no heat escaping, which never happens. The pool loses heat the whole time it is heating, and more of it uncovered.
  • A heat pump loses output as the air cools. DOE says it works efficiently above about 45°F to 50°F, and Hayward and Pentair rate theirs at roughly 60% to 70% of full output in 50°F air. Ask for that 50°F figure rather than the headline.
  • DOE’s formula sizes a heater to raise the water 1°F to 1¼°F an hour. For 2°F an hour, DOE says to double the figure.

Size and speed are different questions

People ask them as one question and they have different answers, which is why heater advice so often sounds contradictory.

Surface area sets the size you need. Heat leaves a pool through the surface, and DOE calls evaporation by far the largest loss, so the load scales with area rather than with how deep the pool is. DOE’s formula is area × temperature rise × 12 for the heater’s output in BTU an hour, where the rise is the water you want minus the average air temperature in the coldest month you swim. A 512 square foot pool held 20 degrees above that air needs about 122,900 BTU an hour.

Volume sets how long it takes. Water takes 8.34 BTU per gallon per degree, so the heat-up is a fixed amount of energy divided by whatever your heater delivers per hour.

The consequence is worth holding onto: a deep pool heats slowly but holds its heat cheaply, and a wide shallow one heats fast and costs a fortune to keep warm. A tanning ledge is lovely and it is a radiator.

The nameplate trap

Two heaters, two numbers, measured differently — and almost nobody says so on the shelf.

Gas heaters are rated by input. A 400,000 BTU heater burns 400,000 BTU of fuel an hour. The standard models from Pentair, Raypak and Jandy are rated 82% to 84% efficient, so at 84% it delivers around 336,000.

Heat pumps are rated by output. A 140,000 BTU heat pump delivers 140,000 BTU an hour. There is no efficiency to subtract, because the rating already is the delivered heat.

So the gas heater is 2.4 times the heat pump, not 2.9. It matters when you are comparing quotes, and it matters more in the other direction: a heat pump that looks like a third of the heater is really about two-fifths of it, which changes the sizing conversation.

What the heat actually costs

Same pool, same 20 degrees, three fuels. Raising 20,000 gallons by 20°F takes 3.3 million BTU delivered.

Natural gas at $1.50 a therm, through an 84% heater: about $60. A heat pump at $0.17 a kWh with a COP of 5: about $33. Propane at $2.55 a gallon: about $111.

The gas and propane prices are the calculator's examples, and what its "Use the US average" button fills in: US residential averages from the EIA, natural gas for 2025, and propane over the 2025–26 heating season, before tax. The 17 cents is a little under the 2026 electricity average.

DOE’s city tables put a heat pump at about half the cost of gas, but the size of the gap is your utility rates, which is why the calculator asks for your own price rather than assuming one. The heat pump advantage is largest against propane and smallest where natural gas is cheap and electricity is expensive.

None of that counts standing losses, which is the cost you actually live with. A cover is the bigger saving: DOE calls covering a pool the single most effective way to cut heating costs, because it stops evaporation while it is on.

Why the answer here is optimistic

Every time and cost above assumes a perfectly insulated pool. Yours is not one, and the gap is not small.

While the heater runs, the pool keeps losing heat, and DOE says evaporation rises with the water temperature and with the wind at the surface, so the warmer you push it, the faster it loses. A cover stops evaporation while it is on, which is why a covered pool comes closest to the figure above.

DOE’s sizing formula builds the losses in: it assumes a heat-up of 1°F to 1¼°F an hour against a 3½ mph wind. That is why its answer is far above the heat it takes simply to warm the water.

Two things make the estimate worse: wind, which DOE says raises evaporation, and a heat pump in cold air, which Hayward and Pentair rate at roughly 60% to 70% of full output at 50°F, and which stops to defrost around there. Which heater suits which climate goes through that properly.

Questions about this calculator

What size pool heater do I need?

DOE’s formula is pool area × temperature rise × 12, which gives the heater’s output in BTU an hour. The rise is the water temperature you want minus the average air temperature in the coldest month you swim. A 16 by 32 pool is 512 square feet, so 80°F water against 60°F air is 512 × 20 × 12 = 122,880 BTU an hour of output. A gas heater at 84% needs about 146,000 BTU of input to deliver that. DOE says the formula assumes the water rises 1°F to 1¼°F an hour against a 3½ mph wind, and to double it for 2°F an hour.

How long does it take to heat a pool?

Water takes 8.34 BTU per gallon per degree, so raising 20,000 gallons by 20°F needs 3.3 million BTU delivered. A 400,000 BTU gas heater delivers about 336,000 an hour after efficiency, so roughly 10 hours with nothing escaping. A 140,000 BTU heat pump delivers 140,000 an hour, so nearer 24. The pool loses heat the whole time, more of it uncovered, so the real figure is longer.

Why is a 400,000 BTU gas heater not three times a 140,000 BTU heat pump?

Because the two numbers measure different things. Gas heaters are rated by fuel input and turn 82% to 84% of it into water temperature on the standard models, so a 400,000 BTU heater at 84% delivers around 336,000. Heat pumps are rated by heat output, so 140,000 means 140,000 delivered. The gas heater is still much faster, but the gap is 2.4 times rather than 2.9.

Is it cheaper to heat a pool with gas or a heat pump?

A heat pump, in DOE’s figures: across its 13 cities, a heat pump cost about half what gas did, because it moves heat rather than making it. Raising 20,000 gallons by 20°F costs about $60 on natural gas at $1.50 a therm, roughly $33 on a heat pump at $0.17 a kWh, and about $111 on propane at $2.55 a gallon. The gap is widest against propane and narrowest where natural gas is cheap and electricity is not.

Put this calculator on your site

Free to use anywhere. Paste this where you want it to appear — the credit line underneath is the only thing I ask for.

<iframe src="https://poolbuff.com/embed/tools/heater-sizing-calculator" width="100%" height="1460" id="poolbuff-heater-sizing-calculator"
  style="border:1px solid #e1e5eb;border-radius:12px;max-width:680px"
  loading="lazy" title="Pool Heater Sizing and Heat-Up Calculator"></iframe>
<p style="font:14px system-ui;margin:8px 0 0">
  <a href="https://poolbuff.com/tools/heater-sizing-calculator">Pool Heater Sizing and Heat-Up Calculator</a> by PoolBuff</p>
<script>window.addEventListener("message",function(e){
  if(e.origin!=="https://poolbuff.com"||!e.data||e.data.type!=="poolbuff:embed-height")return;
  var f=document.getElementById("poolbuff-heater-sizing-calculator");if(f)f.height=e.data.height;});</script>