What it costs to heat a pool depends on three things more than on the brochure: where you live, how warm you keep it, and whether the pool is covered when nobody's in it.
The Department of Energy published season costs for all three, city by city, for gas and for heat pumps. They're the only public figures I've found that put heaters and covers side by side like that. DOE's Energy Saver pages on pool heating have returned errors since July 2026, so the figures here come from archived copies of DOE's own pages. Prices come from the Energy Information Administration, and heater specifications from the makers. Where the sources disagree, I say so.
Key takeaways
- DOE calls covering a pool when it isn't in use the single most effective way to cut heating costs, and says it can save 50% to 70%.
- In DOE's city figures, a heat pump cost about half what gas did to hold the same pool at the same temperature.
- Each degree warmer costs 10% to 30% more in energy, DOE says.
- Heat pumps work efficiently above about 45°F to 50°F, DOE says. Hayward and Pentair rate theirs at roughly 60% to 70% of full output in 50°F air.
- DOE's rule of thumb for solar is collector area equal to 50% to 100% of the pool's surface.
- DOE's cost figures use $1.09 a therm and 13.01 cents a kWh. EIA's 2025 averages are about a third higher, so scale them up.
What DOE says a season costs
| Gas | Gas, covered | Heat pump | Heat pump, covered | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Miami, all year | $3,880 | $796 | $1,989 | $409 |
| Atlanta, April to October | $3,063 | $578 | $1,512 | $279 |
| Phoenix, March to October | $2,420 | $229 | $1,192 | $116 |
| Los Angeles, May to October | $3,237 | $414 | $1,649 | $211 |
| Chicago, May to September | $2,823 | $403 | $1,410 | $204 |
| Seattle, June to August | $2,431 | $578 | $1,226 | $293 |
The cover beats the heater. Across all 13 of DOE's cities, covering the pool cut the gas figure by 73% to 93%. Switching from gas to a heat pump cut it by about half.
The season matters as much as the climate. Miami heats all year and costs the most. Seattle's three-month season costs about what Phoenix's eight months do.
DOE's prices are out of date. Its tables give no date. EIA's 2025 averages were $15.34 per thousand cubic feet of natural gas, about $1.48 a therm, and 17.30 cents a kWh of electricity. That's about 36% more than DOE assumed for gas and 33% more for electricity, so scale the table up by about a third before you budget from it.
Summer gas looks dearer than it is. EIA's residential gas price peaks in summer, $26.45 per thousand cubic feet in July 2026. EIA says that's because fixed charges are spread over less gas in warm weather. So the summer average overstates what each extra therm costs, and the per-therm rate on your own bill is the better number.
Gas, heat pump and solar side by side
| Gas | Heat pump | Solar | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Efficiency | 82% to 96%; the federal minimum is 82% | COP 3.0 to 7.0 under DOE’s test | Rated by heat collected per square foot a day |
| Size | 125,000 to 400,000 Btu an hour of input | 75,000 to 125,000 Btu, DOE’s standard sizes | Collectors equal to 50% to 100% of the pool surface |
| Installed cost | $3,479 on average | $4,117 on average for electric heaters | $2,500 to $4,000 (DOE, undated) |
| Cold air | Works at any temperature | Efficient above about 45°F to 50°F | Heats only when the sun is on the collectors |
| Life, per DOE | Five or more years | 10 or more years | 10 to 20 years |
Gas is the fast one. DOE calls gas heaters "ideal for quickly heating pools," a good choice for a pool used only now and then, and the only type that holds any temperature regardless of the weather.
A heat pump costs more to buy and less to run. DOE says heat pumps "typically have much lower annual operating costs because of their higher efficiencies," and typically last longer than gas heaters.
Solar costs least to run. DOE says it has "very low annual operating costs" and puts its payback at 1 to 7 years, depending on local fuel costs and sun.
On lifespan, DOE disagrees with itself. Its Energy Saver pages give gas heaters "five or more years" and heat pumps "10 or more." Its 2023 rule puts the average life of gas and electric pool heaters at 11.1 years.
Why a cover matters more than the heater
Evaporation is the reason. DOE calls it "by far the largest source of energy loss" from a pool. It takes 1 Btu to warm a pound of water by a degree, but each pound of 80°F water that evaporates takes 1,048 Btu out of the pool.
A cover stops it while it's on. DOE calls covering a pool when it isn't in use "the single most effective means of reducing pool heating costs," and says savings of 50% to 70% are possible. Its own city tables show more, as above.
California now requires one. Its 2025 Energy Code says outdoor pools and spas with gas or electric heating "shall be installed with a pool cover," on the new installations the code covers.
The catch is using it. A cover only saves while it's on the pool, so it has to come off and go back on every day. A reel makes that easier, and an automatic cover does it for you, but Coverstar puts one at $10,000 to $20,000, which makes it its own decision. The solar cover guide covers the cheap end.
Go deeperWhich pool cover to buySolar, safety, winter and automatic compared on cost, heat retention and hassle.The temperature question
Each degree costs 10% to 30% more. DOE says that's the extra energy cost for each degree, higher in warm climates because heating to 78°F costs so little there. Its own city tables put each 2°F step at 15% to 33%.
Where to set it. DOE says pool water typically runs 78°F to 82°F. It cites the American Red Cross recommending 78°F for competitive swimming, and says that may be too cool for young children and older people, who may want 80°F or more.
Turn it down when nobody's swimming. DOE says to turn the temperature down, or the heater off, when the pool won't be used for several days. It calls it a myth that heating the pool back up takes more energy than you saved.
Working out your own number
DOE's table is a guide, and your own rates can move it a long way. The arithmetic is short enough to do once.
What a degree costs you. Water takes 8.34 Btu per gallon per degree, so a 20,000-gallon pool needs about 167,000 Btu of delivered heat for each degree of rise.
What delivered heat costs on gas. A therm is 100,000 Btu of gas. The federal minimum efficiency for a gas pool heater is 82%, and the standard models from Pentair, Raypak and Jandy are rated 82% to 84%. At 84% and EIA's 2025 average of about $1.48 a therm, delivered heat costs about $17.60 per million Btu.
What it costs on a heat pump. A kilowatt-hour is 3,412 Btu, and a heat pump delivers that times its COP. At a COP of 5.0, the seasonal average DOE used, that's about 17,000 Btu per kWh. At EIA's 2025 average of 17.30 cents, delivered heat costs about $10 per million Btu. The heat pump wiring guide has what each model draws in an hour.
Or let the heater calculator do it, with your own prices.
Put the two together. Raising that pool by ten degrees takes 20,000 gallons × 8.34 × 10 = 1,668,000 Btu. That's about $29 on natural gas at those rates and about $17 on the heat pump, before any heat escapes.
Propane changes the answer. EIA's residential propane price for the week of 5 October 2026 was $2.598 a gallon before tax, and a gallon holds 91,452 Btu. That works out near $2.84 a therm, a little under twice the 2025 natural gas average, and the same ten degrees costs about $56.
None of that counts what the pool loses while it heats, which is what the cover is for.
Wind and windbreaks
Wind raises evaporation. DOE says the evaporation rate rises with the pool's temperature and the wind speed at its surface, and falls as the humidity rises. Its heater sizing formula assumes an average wind of 3½ miles an hour at the surface.
A windbreak helps. In windy spots, DOE suggests trees, shrubs or a fence. It has to be high enough and close enough to the pool that it doesn't stir up turbulence over the water, which increases evaporation. It also shouldn't shade the pool, because the sun helps heat it.
What climate changes
Heat pumps need mild air. DOE says they work efficiently while the outside air stays above the 45°F to 50°F range, and lose efficiency below it. More on that in the heat pump section below.
Gas doesn't care. DOE says a gas heater can hold any temperature regardless of the weather or climate.
Solar needs more collector where it's cooler or cloudier. DOE's example: a 15-by-30-foot pool in Florida used all year needs collectors equal to 100% of its surface, 450 square feet. In northern California, where DOE says people use outdoor pools 6 to 8 months a year, systems are typically sized at 60% to 70%. A cover reduces the area needed in any climate.
For how each type is sized and where the marketing figures fall apart, see pool heaters compared.
Gas specifics
They're rated by input. Pentair's residential gas heaters run from 125,000 to 400,000 Btu an hour, Raypak's from 199,000 to 399,000 and Jandy's JXi from 200,000 to 399,000. DOE's page describes gas heaters by output, 75,000 to 450,000 Btu, which isn't the same number.
The quick math. A 400,000 Btu heater burns 400,000 Btu of gas an hour, which is 4 therms, whatever its efficiency. Ten hours is 40 therms, about $59 at the 2025 average. Three or four sessions a month is about $180 to $240.
Efficiency is set by law and by the heat exchanger. The federal minimum has been 82% since 2013, and a new standard, measured a different way, applies from 30 May 2028. Pentair's MasterTemp is rated 84% with a copper exchanger and 82% with cupro-nickel, Raypak's AVIA 84% and its Digital 82%, and Jandy's JXi 83% to 84%. Pentair's condensing ETi heaters are rated 94% to 96%.
Propane costs more than natural gas for the same heat, as above. Check which you have before budgeting.
Heat pump specifics
Heat pumps move heat from the air rather than making it, which is why they're so much cheaper per degree.
The catch is that output drops as the air gets colder. The makers' headline figure is quoted at 80°F air, 80% humidity and 80°F water; DOE's federal test uses 63% humidity instead, and DOE puts COPs at 3.0 to 7.0 under it. Hayward and Pentair both publish a second rating at 50°F air, and on their current heat pumps it comes to roughly 60 to 70 percent of the headline number, at a COP of 4 rather than 5.5 to 6.1.
The harder limit is frost. Around 50°F the air coil has to defrost, and the heat pump stops heating while it does. Pentair's UltraTemp stops its compressor for about 15 minutes and shuts down with a Low Ambient Temp alarm if that does not clear the coil; Hayward's HeatPro manual puts a defrost at anything from 15 minutes to several hours. In genuinely cold air, that is where the time goes.
Which means the manufacturer's headline Btu number is optimistic for how you'll actually use it in April and October, exactly the months you bought it for.
Size generously and check the output curve at your realistic shoulder-season temperatures, not at 80°F.
Solar specifics
Panels on a roof, water pumped through them, the sun does the work. DOE says switching from a conventional heater may need a bigger pump, or a separate small one, to move water through the collectors.
You need area. DOE's rule of thumb is collector area equal to 50% to 100% of the pool's surface. The makers differ: Heliocol calls 75% to 100% optimal, while Enersol says 50% to 75%, with 50% for panels facing south. California's code sets 60% as the minimum for a new solar pool heating system. DOE says collectors can face up to 45° east or west of true south without losing much.
It's weather-dependent. No sun, no heat. So it extends your season rather than giving you heat on demand.
Cost and life. DOE puts a system at $2,500 to $4,000 installed, a figure it doesn't date, on a page with sections dated 2012. It says a system lasts 10 to 20 years. Warranties vary: Heliocol's is 12 years, limited, and Enersol's is 18 years but prorated down to 10% from year 13, and it excludes labor.
Pairing. California's 2025 code counts solar plus a heat pump, with no other heater, as one of the ways a new pool heating system can comply.
Go deeperGetting a solar cover rightWhich side goes down, what DOE says a cover saves, and the safety point that matters.Where the sources disagree
- What a cover saves. DOE's covers page says 50% to 70%. Its own city tables, with the pool uncovered 8 hours a day, show 73% to 93%.
- What a degree costs. DOE says each degree costs 10% to 30% more. Its city tables put each 2°F step at 15% to 33%, which is closer to 7% to 15% a degree.
- Heat pump against gas. DOE's heat pump page says a heat pump at a COP of 5.0 costs $700 a year where a 55% efficient gas heater costs $1,000. At the prices DOE gives, a COP of 5.0 works out nearer $385. Its city tables, against an 80% gas heater, put the heat pump at about half.
- One city figure. DOE's heat pump table gives Dallas at 78°F, uncovered, as $491, a quarter of the gas figure where every other entry is about half. It isn't used here.
- How long heaters last. DOE's Energy Saver pages say five or more years for gas and 10 or more for heat pumps. Its 2023 rule averages 11.1 years for both.
- Where heat pumps stop being efficient. The same DOE page says both "above 50° Fahrenheit" and "above the 45ºF–50ºF range."
- How heat pumps are rated. The makers quote 80% humidity; DOE's federal test uses 63%.
- How gas heaters are rated. DOE describes them by output. Pentair, Raypak and Jandy rate them by input.
- The best gas efficiency. DOE says some gas heaters reach 89% to 95%. Pentair rates its ETi 400 at 96%. DOE's savings tables also start from a 55% heater, below the 82% federal minimum in force since 2013.
- Solar collector area. DOE says 50% to 100%, Heliocol 75% to 100%, Enersol 50% to 75%, and California requires at least 60%.
Frequently asked questions
How much does it cost to heat a pool per month?
DOE gives the figures per season rather than per month. For a 1,000-square-foot pool at 80°F, gas cost $2,420 to $3,880 a season uncovered across 13 cities, and a heat pump $1,158 to $1,989. Covered when not in use, gas cost $229 to $796. DOE used $1.09 a therm and 13.01 cents a kWh; EIA's 2025 averages are about a third higher.
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas pool heater?
Yes, in DOE's figures: a heat pump cost about half what gas did in every city it listed. DOE says heat pumps cost more to buy but typically have much lower operating costs. The trade-offs are slower heating and output that falls in cool air: DOE says they work efficiently above about 45°F to 50°F, and Hayward and Pentair rate theirs at roughly 60% to 70% of full output in 50°F air.
How much does a pool cover save on heating?
DOE says 50% to 70% of heating costs, and calls covering a pool when it isn't in use the single most effective way to cut them. Its own city tables show more: with the pool uncovered 8 hours a day, the gas bill fell by 73% to 93%. Evaporation is the reason, and a cover stops it while it's on.
What temperature should I keep my pool?
DOE says pool water typically runs 78°F to 82°F, and cites the American Red Cross recommending 78°F for competitive swimming. It adds that 78°F may be too cool for young children and older people, who may want 80°F or more. Each degree warmer costs 10% to 30% more in energy, by DOE's figure.
Should I turn the pool heater off when I'm not using the pool?
DOE says yes: turn the temperature down, or the heater off, when the pool won't be used for several days. It calls it a myth that heating the pool back up takes more energy than you saved.
Is solar pool heating worth it?
DOE puts a solar pool heater at $2,500 to $4,000 installed, with a payback of 1 to 7 years depending on fuel costs and sun, and says it lasts 10 to 20 years. Those figures are undated. It needs collector area equal to 50% to 100% of the pool's surface, and it only heats when the sun is on the panels.



