A good chunk of my fifteen-plus years in this industry was equipment repair and warranty work. That meant a lot of visits to houses where a pump had stopped priming and something expensive had supposedly died.
The number of times it was actually the pump? Small. The number of times it was a ten-dollar o-ring, a full skimmer basket or a water level four inches too low? Most of them. I got a bit sheepish about the invoice on some of those calls.
So before anybody talks about replacing anything, work through this in order. It's cheapest first, and close to the order the pump makers check in.
Key takeaways
- Never primes and loses prime later are two different problems with different causes.
- While the pump runs, suction-side leaks pull air in, so you won't see water. Pressure-side leaks drip.
- In my repair work, the lid o-ring was at fault more often than any other part. Pentair lists its common ones at $6 to $9.
- Fill the pump with water and open the filter's air relief valve before restarting. Never run it dry: water is what cools the shaft seal.
- Lubricate the lid o-ring with what your pump's manual names, and never petroleum jelly. Jandy's variable-speed manuals say soapy water only.
First, work out which problem you have
These get lumped together and they're not the same.
It never primes. Start it, it churns air, water never arrives. Look for a bigger air leak, a blockage, a closed valve, or no water reaching the skimmer.
It primes, then loses prime. It catches, runs fine, then you come back and there's a pocket of air in the lid and no flow. Look for a small air leak that takes time to build up, or a water level that drops during the run until the skimmer draws air.
If it loses prime while it is switched off, check where it sits. Jandy recommends a check valve on the suction line when a pump is more than 2 feet above the water, to keep the plumbing full while the pump is off.
It primes but flow is weak. That's a different article — you're looking at restriction, not prime loss.
Knowing which one you've got narrows things down before you touch anything.
One case isn't a fault at all. Some above-ground pumps don't self-prime. Hayward's manual says its PowerFlo LX and EP series must be installed below the pool's water line, while the PowerFlo II primes itself from up to 4 feet above it.
Understand which side you're on
Suction side — skimmer, main drain, the pipes running to the pump, the pump lid. (Every term here is defined in the glossary if any of it is unfamiliar.) While the pump runs, a leak here pulls air in, so you won't see water. That's why suction leaks are so much harder to find.
Pressure side — everything after the pump. A leak here pushes water out. You'll see a drip, a spray or a wet patch.
If you can see water leaking while the pump runs, that is not what's stopping your prime. Fix it, but keep looking.
Priming it, step by step
Before you start
- Time
- 1 hr
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Cost
- $4-$30 in parts
Tools
- Screwdriver or filter clamp tool
- Garden hose
- Bucket
- Large tongue-and-groove pliers
Supplies
- Pump lid o-ring
- The o-ring lubricant your pump manual names
- Drain plug and union o-rings
- 1
Water level
30 secondsPentair's skimmer and pump manuals put the target about halfway up the skimmer opening.
Below the opening, Pentair says, the pump draws air through the skimmer and loses its prime.
Top it off with the hose and try again. Watch for it after a hot week, after a party where a lot of water splashed out, or when there's a slow leak elsewhere that nobody's noticed yet. EPA's pool guide notes that hotter water evaporates faster, so a heated pool without a cover loses more.
Also check the skimmer weir — the flap in the skimmer mouth. Hayward's PowerFlo manual puts a weir that is hung up on the skimmer wall on its won't-prime list, and Pentair says to check that the weir moves freely.
- 2
The pump lid o-ring
5 minIn my repair work, this was the part at fault more often than any other.
Pump off. Pull the lid. Take the o-ring out and look at it properly:
- Cracked or crazed? Replace it.
- Flattened, squared off instead of round? Replace it.
- Hard and stiff rather than supple? Replace it.
- Dry? Clean the groove and the sealing surface, lubricate it with what your pump's manual names, and reseat.
Pentair lists its own lid o-rings at $6.04 for the WhisperFlo and IntelliFlo VS and $8.84 for the SuperFlo, but $27.86 for the IntelliFlo3 and $29.77 for the XF pumps. Those are list prices, which run above what shops charge. Aladdin's copies cost about $4 to $15 on its own store.
The lubricant depends on the maker:
- Hayward names Jack's 327 in its manuals, and its support site recommends a silicone or Teflon-based lubricant.
- Pentair says to keep the lid o-ring clean and well lubricated, without naming a product. The IntelliFlo3 guide says only to keep it clean.
- Jandy's variable-speed manuals say soapy water only, with no lubricant or sealant on the o-ring. The VS FloPro manual's own troubleshooting table then suggests a very small amount of silicone, and no Vaseline.
Never petroleum jelly: Jandy says petroleum-based grease will destroy the o-ring. The makers' own lubricants run about $4 to $20 depending on size.
While the lid's off, clean the seat the o-ring sits in. Jandy's manual says debris around the lid o-ring seat may cause an air leak and make the pump hard to prime.
Then refit the lid by hand. Hayward says by hand only, no wrenches, and Jandy says to hand-tighten it to make an air-tight seal without tools. Pentair's IntelliFlo3 guide says to check the o-ring is seated and not pinched between the lid and the pot.
- 3
Both baskets
5 minSkimmer basket first. Hayward lists a basket loaded with debris among the reasons a pump won't prime.
Then the pump basket, with the pump off. Empty it and check it for cracks. Pentair says to replace a cracked basket, and Jandy's manual links debris at the impeller to a broken one, which is how you end up with the problem in step 7.
Pentair lists its baskets at $26.77 for the WhisperFlo and IntelliFlo and $34.93 for the SuperFlo, and Aladdin's copies are about $10. If it's cracked, replace it rather than nursing it along.
- 4
Open every valve
1 minThe water needs somewhere to go before the pump can prime.
Hayward says every suction and discharge valve must be open when the pump starts. Its PowerFlo manual puts a closed or blocked valve on the won't-prime list, and Pentair's start-up checklist says the return line must be completely open and clear.
A dirty filter is not on any maker's won't-prime list. Hayward puts a plugged filter under low flow, where the gauge reads high. If the pressure was already high before this started, clean the filter anyway, but don't expect it to fix the prime.
- 5
Fill the housing and watch
10 minFill the strainer housing with water up to the suction port, which is the level Hayward and Pentair give. Open the air relief valve on top of the filter. Refit the lid by hand and start the pump. Close the air relief valve once water, not air, comes out of it in a steady stream.
Now watch through the clear lid:
- Catches and runs clear — you had a one-time prime loss. Watch it for half an hour to see if it holds.
- Fills with a swirling vortex of air that never clears — active air leak. Go to step 6.
- Water level in the basket drops steadily while running — active air leak. Go to step 6.
- Doesn't move water at all despite the motor running — go to step 7, likely a blockage or an impeller problem.
Give it the priming time your manual allows, and no more. Hayward allows 5 to 15 minutes depending on the model. Pentair gives its SuperFlo VS a 5-minute window and says never to let an IntelliFlo3 run more than 30 minutes without priming. Jandy's variable-speed pumps take about 15 minutes at their priming speed from 10 feet above the water.
If it hasn't caught by then, stop and find the cause. Running dry damages the shaft seal, which water cools. And Pentair warns that a pump that failed to prime can hold scalding water under pressure, so let the pot cool before you open it.
- 6
Find the air leak
20 minWork along the suction side, using the makers' own checks.
Jandy's manual says to try tightening the suction-side union while the pump is running. If air still gets in, shut the pump off, take the union apart, and clean and reinstall its o-rings. Hand-tightening a union with clean o-rings should seal it. If it doesn't, Jandy says to tighten it gently with large tongue-and-groove pliers, and not to over-tighten.
Then the rest of the suction side:
- Pipe connections. Hayward's list starts with loose connections on the suction side.
- Valve stems. Hayward lists leaking o-rings or packing glands on valves, and Pentair says to check the glands on any suction gate valves.
- The drain plugs on the pump housing. Each seals with its own o-ring, so check and replace the o-ring rather than taping the threads.
- A suction cleaner hose, if one runs off the skimmer. Pentair lists a split hose as a source of air in the pump.
If a threaded fitting has to be remade, Hayward says to seal it with PTFE tape and never with pipe dope, which can crack the plastic.
If none of that finds it, Hayward's last check is the suction itself. It says the pump should pull 5 to 6 inches of vacuum at the strainer cover, and that only your pool dealer can confirm it with a vacuum gauge.
- 7
Check the impeller
20 minKill the power at the breaker. Not the timer, not the switch. Jandy and Pentair both say the breaker.
Remove the pump basket and look into the impeller eye. You're looking for hair, string, small leaves or a pebble wedged in the vanes, and Hayward's won't-prime checks include the impeller. Clear what you can reach through the basket opening. If it means opening the pump, Hayward says to have a qualified repair professional do it.
US Motors says to try spinning the motor shaft by hand from the back of the motor. If it doesn't spin freely, it names a tight pump seal, something caught in the pump housing, or a bad bearing.
What it costs when it's actually broken
Worth knowing before somebody quotes you a new pump. Pentair's figures are its 2025–2026 list prices, which run above what shops charge. Hayward's are its 2026 minimum advertised prices for whole pumps. Hayward and Jandy publish no parts prices.
| Failure | Part cost | Who the makers say should do it |
|---|---|---|
| Lid o-ring | $4–$30 | You |
| Pump basket | $10–$55 | You |
| Union o-rings | $2–$19 | You, by hand, then gently with pliers |
| Valve stem o-rings | $4–$17 | You |
| Mechanical seal kit | $37–$54 | Hayward: qualified personnel only |
| Impeller | $87–$160 | Hayward: a qualified repair professional |
| Motor | $669–$1,332, single-speed | A licensed electrician for the wiring |
| Whole pump | $749–$2,999 in-ground | A licensed electrician for the wiring |
In my repair work, most no-prime calls ended in the top three rows or at the water level. If someone jumps straight to the bottom row without walking the list above, get a second opinion.
On a Hayward Super Pump, the impeller depends on the model — the Super Pump page matches impeller numbers to models in its fitment table. Check for a blockage before ordering, though: a blocked impeller and a worn one present differently, and only one needs a part.
Seasonal patterns worth knowing
Spring opening. Everything has sat for months. Hayward's opening checklist says to lubricate or replace the o-rings on pump lids and plumbing connections, then power up and check for leaks.
Fall. Leaf drop fills skimmer baskets, and a loaded basket is on Hayward's won't-prime list. Empty them more often than your usual schedule while the trees are dropping.
Mid-summer. Check the water level. EPA says evaporation is faster from hotter water, and it only suspects a leak past 2 inches a week, or 3 in hot, dry areas.
After anyone's worked on the pad. A union that wasn't retightened, or an o-ring that got pinched on reassembly: Pentair's IntelliFlo3 guide warns about pinching the lid and seal plate o-rings. If the problem started right after a service visit, that's where to look first.
When to hand it over
Call somebody when:
- You've confirmed an air leak but traced it to an underground pipe — that's excavation
- The motor hums but doesn't spin, or trips the breaker — see why a pool pump won't turn on
- There's water in the motor — Pentair says not to run a pump that has been flooded
- The fix means opening the pump for a jammed impeller or a shaft seal, which Hayward reserves for qualified professionals
- Anything electrical — Hayward says wiring must be done by a qualified professional, and Jandy and Pentair say a licensed electrician
Pool equipment also has to be bonded under NEC Article 680, as Jandy's manual puts it, and Hayward and Pentair specify a solid copper bonding wire of No. 8 AWG. The makers give owners the water level, the baskets, the lid o-ring and priming. The rest belongs to a professional.
Go deeperIf the air is coming from the skimmerWeak suction, air in the basket, and how to tell a cracked skimmer from a bad gasket.Before you start
- Price at Amazon: silicone lubricant
silicone lubricant
Silicone, never petroleum. Jandy says petroleum-based grease will destroy an o-ring.
Frequently asked questions
Why won't my pool pump prime?
Air is getting into the suction side, or water can't reach the pump. Hayward's checks run in this order: an empty strainer housing or a bad lid o-ring, loose suction connections, leaking valve o-rings, baskets loaded with debris, then a clogged suction line. Pentair's add a water level low enough for the skimmer to draw air.
How long can a pool pump run without water?
No maker gives a safe time. Hayward says never run the pump dry, because water cools and lubricates the shaft seal, and Jandy says running dry for any length of time causes severe damage. Fill the strainer housing before you start it. Once it is full, the makers allow a priming window: 5 to 15 minutes on Hayward's pumps, and at most 30 on Pentair's IntelliFlo3.
How do I find an air leak in my pool pump suction line?
Work along the suction side. Jandy's manual says to try tightening the suction-side union with the pump running, then clean and reinstall its o-rings if air still gets in. Check the lid o-ring, the drain plug o-rings, and the stem o-rings or packing glands on any suction-side valves. If those are sound, Hayward says a pool dealer can check the suction with a vacuum gauge.
Why does my pool pump lose prime after running for a while?
A small air leak that takes time to build up in the basket, or a water level that drops during the run until the skimmer draws air. If the pump loses prime while it is off and sits more than 2 feet above the water, the water may be draining back. Jandy recommends a check valve on the suction line for that case.
Can a dirty filter stop a pool pump from priming?
Not according to the makers' troubleshooting tables. None lists a clogged filter under failure to prime; Hayward lists it under low flow, with a high gauge reading. What does matter at startup is that every return valve is open and the filter's air relief valve is open, so trapped air has somewhere to go.
Do I need to replace the pump if it won't prime?
Almost never. In my repair and warranty work, most no-prime calls came down to a $10 o-ring, a full basket, a low water level or a loose union. Replace the pump only after you've confirmed the motor runs, the impeller is clear and turning, and there's genuinely no air leak.



