In my experience, most skimmer complaints aren't broken skimmers.
They're the water level, or a basket packed with wet leaves that don't look like much. Both take thirty seconds to rule out, and doing that first saves a lot of pointless investigating.
When it really is the skimmer, here's how to tell the possibilities apart.
Key takeaways
- Check the level and the basket before anything else. In my experience, that's where most skimmer complaints end.
- A suction leak pulls air in and never drips, which is why it hides so well.
- Water that falls to the bottom of the skimmer opening and stops points at the skimmer or its faceplate.
- On vinyl pools, the faceplate gasket was the skimmer leak I found most often.
- Air in the pump basket comes from before the pump, never after it.
Start with the free checks
- 1
Look at the water level
About halfway up the skimmer opening. Pentair says never within 1 inch of the top or bottom. Too high and the floating weir is pinned against the top of the opening, so there's no surface flow over it. In my experience, this is where most skimmer complaints start, and it looks like nothing is wrong.
- 2
Pull the basket
Wet leaves pack flat and restrict flow long before the basket looks full. Pentair warns that a clogged skimmer basket can damage the pump through cavitation. Empty it and watch whether suction picks up right away.
- 3
Check the weir moves
It should swing freely and float back up. In my experience, a jammed or missing weir is a regular cause of a pool that doesn't skim. Pentair lists a replacement Bermuda weir at $34.22.
- 4
Check the suction valve
If you have two skimmers and a main drain on a three-way valve, the handle position decides how much each one gets. Somebody may have moved it.
If suction is back, you're done. If not, keep going.
Finding a suction leak
Here's the thing that makes these hard: a suction leak doesn't drip.
The pipe between your skimmer and pump is under vacuum while the pump runs. A hole there doesn't leak water out, it pulls air in. So there's no wet patch to find, no trickle on the ground, nothing to see.
What you get instead:
- Bubbles in the pump basket while it's running
- Bubbles from the return jets, especially at startup
- Weak or surging suction at the skimmer
- Pump losing prime after it shuts off
Air in the basket can only come from before the pump. That narrows it to the skimmer, the pipe to the pump, the pump lid and its o-ring, and any drain plugs.
Check the pump lid o-ring first regardless. In my repair work, it let in more air than anything else, and Pentair lists its common ones at $6 to $9. Lubricate it with what your pump's manual names, often a silicone lubricant, and never petroleum jelly: Jandy says petroleum-based grease will destroy an o-ring. Jandy's variable-speed manuals say soapy water only.
Go deeperPump won't hold prime?The full diagnostic order for a pump that will not prime or will not keep it.Is the skimmer itself leaking?
There's a clean test for this, and it costs nothing.
Turn the pump off and let the pool lose water on its own. Watch where it stops.
Water finds the level of the leak. So:
- Drops to the bottom of the skimmer opening and stops there. The leak is at that height. That's the skimmer, its faceplate, or the pipe right at the back of it.
- Keeps dropping past that. The leak is lower down. Light niche, return fitting, main drain, a plumbing run. Not the skimmer.
- Doesn't drop beyond normal evaporation. No leak. You have a flow problem, not a leak problem.
That one observation rules out most of the pool in an afternoon.
Where skimmers leak
The faceplate gasket, on a vinyl pool. The skimmer body is behind the liner, and the liner is clamped to it by a faceplate and a row of screws with a gasket between. That gasket hardens, the screws loosen, and water gets behind the liner. On vinyl pools, it's the skimmer leak I found most often, and it's a small job: a gasket, a screw set and an afternoon. Pentair lists the Bermuda's faceplate kit at $137.56.
The through-wall gasket, on an above-ground pool. Same idea: the liner is sandwiched between the faceplate, a gasket and the skimmer body. In my experience, an above-ground pool losing water at the skimmer has a gasket problem.
A crack in the skimmer body. On a concrete pool the body is set into the shell, so where the crack runs decides the job. If it reaches the pipe connection or the shell, it's the next one.
Separation at the pipe or the shell. The skimmer has pulled away from the plumbing behind it, or from the shell it's set into. This is the expensive one. There's no reaching it without breaking out deck or shell, and once you're there you're replacing the skimmer anyway.
What replacement actually costs
In my experience, replacing an in-ground skimmer ran from several hundred dollars to a few thousand installed.
The skimmer isn't most of that. Getting to one generally means cutting deck or shell, doing the work, then repairing the surface you cut. What has to come out, and what has to be made good afterward, decides the quote.
Which is the argument for catching a faceplate gasket early. It's a cheap job right up until it isn't. Hayward warns, of its above-ground skimmer, that ongoing leaks at the skimmer or wall fittings can damage the pool wall until it fails.
When it's not the skimmer at all
Worth ruling these out before you commit to anything invasive:
The pump is on too low a speed. Pentair says a skimmer needs 10 to 55 gallons a minute through it to perform, and Florida's code designs each skimmer for at least 25. A variable-speed pump run very slow may not pull enough to work the weir. Try a higher speed for a few minutes and see if skimming returns.
The filter is overdue. High filter pressure means less flow everywhere, including your skimmer.
Return jets pointed wrong. Hayward's European manual recommends facing the returns toward the skimmer to push debris to it. Aim them so the surface drifts toward it.
Wind. Pentair says to place skimmers so the prevailing wind blows into them. A skimmer on the upwind side spends its life waiting for debris the wind is blowing the other way. Nothing is broken. The pool was just built that way.
Go deeperHow the whole thing is meant to workEvery part explained, and the water level that decides all of it.Cheap parts worth stocking
- Price at Amazon: silicone lubricant
silicone lubricant
Silicone, never petroleum. Jandy says petroleum-based grease will destroy an o-ring.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my pool skimmer not sucking?
In my experience, most skimmer complaints are the water level or a packed basket. Pentair says to keep the water about halfway up the opening and never within an inch of the top. After that, check the weir moves, check the suction valve hasn't been moved away from that skimmer, and then look for an air leak on the suction side.
Why is there air in my pump basket?
Air can only get in before the pump, so the leak is on the suction side: the skimmer, the pipe between skimmer and pump, the pump lid o-ring, or a drain plug. A pressure-side leak drips water on the ground instead, because that side is pushing rather than pulling.
How do I know if my pool skimmer is cracked?
Let the pool lose water with the pump off. If it drops to the bottom of the skimmer opening and then stops, the leak is at that level, which means the skimmer or its faceplate. If it keeps going past that, the leak is lower down, somewhere else.
Can you repair a cracked pool skimmer?
It depends where it's leaking. A leaking faceplate on a vinyl pool is a gasket and screws, and Pentair lists the Bermuda's faceplate kit at $137.56. A skimmer that's cracked through or has separated from the pipe or the shell needs replacing, which means breaking out deck or shell around it.
How much does it cost to replace a pool skimmer?
In my experience, replacing an in-ground skimmer ran from several hundred dollars to a few thousand installed. The skimmer isn't most of that. Reaching it usually means cutting deck or shell and then repairing the surface, and what has to come out decides the bill.



