Skip to content
PoolBuff

How to Test Pool Water (And Why Strips Mislead You)

By Robert Henry

Where to take the sample, which test kit to buy, how often each test needs doing, and the reading errors that send people chasing problems they don't have.

By Robert Henry

Pool service and repair, 15+ years

7 min read(last month)

I earn a commission if you buy through links here, at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How that works

The short answer

Take the sample 18 inches down, about elbow depth, away from returns, and test it right away. Taylor's kit card says to test free chlorine and pH daily, alkalinity weekly, and calcium and stabilizer monthly. A drop-count FAS-DPD kit is more accurate than strips.

7 min read
A gloved hand holding a clear test vial of pool water tinted deep pink
Strips get you close. A drop kit tells you what to actually do.

Every decision you make about your pool starts with a test result. Which means a bad test result produces a bad decision, and then you're adding chemicals to fix a problem that doesn't exist.

I've watched people shock a perfectly fine pool because a two-year-old strip read low. That's $40 and an afternoon, spent on nothing.

Key takeaways

  • Sample 18 inches down, away from returns and chemical feeders, and test it right away. Taylor and CDC's pool code both use that depth.
  • Strips are less accurate than a DPD drop kit, CDC says, though high chlorine cannot bleach a strip the way it bleaches a DPD test.
  • A FAS-DPD kit counts drops instead of matching colors, and Taylor's free chlorine test in it carries NSF's top accuracy rating.
  • Taylor says to replace reagents once a year and store them between 36°F and 85°F.
  • Write readings down with the date. The trend is worth more than any single test.

Take the sample properly

Eighteen inches down. Taylor's instruction cards say to take samples 18 inches below the surface, and its sampling guide calls that elbow depth. Push the bottle in upside down, turn it over at depth, and bring it up full. CDC's pool code uses the same depth, and its annex gives the reason: sunlight acts on the water at the surface, and most of a pool's contaminants sit in the top 18 inches.

Away from the returns. Taylor says to stay away from return lines and chemical feeders. On a salt pool the difference is big enough that Pentair and Jandy use it as a test: water at the return should read higher than water away from it.

Test it right away. Taylor says letting a sample sit for even a few minutes can change the result, especially the chlorine reading. Hach's lab method for free chlorine says the same: analyze immediately, because the sample cannot be kept.

What to buy

Taylor list priceGood forNot good for
Test strips$13.67-$29.74A quick reading. High chlorine cannot bleach a strip the way it bleaches DPDLess accurate than a DPD kit, per CDC. Moisture ruins them
OTO kit$17.21 (K-1000)pH and total chlorineMeasures total chlorine only, so it cannot separate free from combined
DPD color kit$36.21-$114.47 (K-1004 to K-2005)Free and total chlorineColor steps. Taylor's K-1005 scale stops at 5 ppm, the K-2005's at 10
FAS-DPD drop kitFrom $142.71 (K-2006)Chlorine by counting drops: 0.2 ppm a drop, or 0.5 on a smaller sample that reads to 20 ppmCosts more
Digital photometerLaMotte publishes no priceRemoves color judgmentNeeds checking against a standard, and the reagents still age
Taylor's own store, October 9, 2026. Retail prices can be lower. If you're buying one thing, buy the FAS-DPD kit.

Why FAS-DPD is different. Instead of matching a pink shade to a color block, you count drops until pink turns clear. Taylor says the method suits people who have trouble matching shades of pink. Its instruction card rates the FAS-DPD free chlorine test L1, NSF's top accuracy class, against L3 for the color-match DPD test.

It also covers a shock. With a 25 mL sample each drop is 0.2 ppm. Taylor says more than 50 drops makes the error too large, so for high readings you switch to a 10 mL sample at 0.5 ppm a drop, which reads to 20 ppm. Taylor's color-match DPD test stops at 10, and above that Taylor and CDC both say the sample can bleach out and read falsely low.

Photometers take color judgment out of it, which is LaMotte's pitch for its ColorQ. You can't calibrate one yourself. LaMotte has you check the meter against a performance standard at intervals, for example after 10 hours of use, and its accuracy ratings assume reagents within a 12-month shelf life.

The test kit pages here take four of the kinds in that table apart: AquaChek strips, Taylor's K-2005 DPD color kit, the K-2006C FAS-DPD kit and LaMotte's ColorQ photometer.

What you need

What to test, and when

The makers don't agree on how often, and the spread is wide:

WhoFree chlorine and pHAlkalinityCalciumStabilizerSalt
CDC, home poolsAt least twice a day————
Taylor's K-1005 cardDailyWeeklyMonthlyMonthly—
AquaChekAt least 2 to 3 times a week————
Pentair IntelliChlorWeeklyWeeklyMonthlyMonthlyMonthly
Hayward AquaRite 900WeeklyMonthlyEvery three monthsMonthlyMonthly

Taylor makes the test kit this page recommends, so its card is the schedule to start from. Test more often when the pool is busy: CDC says so, and AquaChek adds a test after a party, heavy rain, or animals in the pool.

Combined chlorine comes out of the same test as free chlorine, by subtracting free from total. Taylor puts the ideal at zero, and says shocking may be necessary above 0.4 ppm, the same line CDC's pool code uses. PHTA's maximum for pools is stricter, at 0.2. This site uses 0.4.

Reagents expire, and it matters

This catches everybody eventually.

Taylor's cards say to replace reagents once a year and keep them in a cool, dark place. Its FAQ puts that at 36°F to 85°F, out of direct sunlight and away from pool chemicals. A kit that has spent two summers in a shed is past both.

Buy refills rather than a whole new kit.

Store the kit indoors. Not the shed, not the pool box.

Know the signs. Taylor says a reagent that has changed color or grown particles that won't dissolve should go. DPD reagent #2 darkens to brown or pink as it ages, for example. One reading that looks like a dead reagent may not be one: a test that reads zero right after a big dose can be chlorine above 10 ppm bleaching the sample, which Taylor fixes by diluting it.

Sanity check against a professional. Pentair's and Jandy's salt cell manuals both say to take a sample to a pool professional once a month. If their numbers and yours disagree, one of you has a problem, and it's worth finding out which.

Taking a sample to the store, and reading what comes back

Free store testing is a useful cross-check, and it's worth knowing how to get a good result out of it.

Collect it the same way as above: 18 inches down, away from returns. Taylor says to use a clean plastic bottle that holds 8 to 12 ounces.

Take it in right away. Chlorine changes within minutes, and temperature moves the stabilizer test: LaMotte says a warm sample can read low and a cold one high. A sample that has sat in a hot car is a worse sample.

Read the printout with a little skepticism. LaMotte sells its WaterLink Spin Touch photometer for in-store testing. Its WaterLink Pro software writes the treatment recommendations, set up so they match the products the store sells. It stores customer records, so it knows your history only if the store keeps one for you.

Use the numbers, weigh the shopping list, and compare against your own kit. Two readings that agree give you confidence in both. Two that disagree tell you to find out why before acting on either.

The tests you do not need monthly

Three get sold as routine. Each has a reason to run it and a reason it can wait.

Phosphates. PHTA says phosphate does not use up chlorine directly, because the phosphate ion does not react with free chlorine. Algae use it when sanitizing falls short. Salt cell makers want it low anyway: Pentair's manual says phosphates should not exceed 125 ppb, and LaMotte puts its limit at 100 ppb to protect the cell. The phosphate page covers when it's worth acting on.

Metals. PHTA says to test fill water before you fill. It also says most metals in a pool arrive after the fill: copper from a gas heater's heat exchanger when water is unbalanced, copper algaecides and mineral systems, and iron from stone that leaches it after rain. So test after any of those, and whenever you see staining.

Total dissolved solids. The number doesn't say what dissolved. PHTA's table still sets a maximum, 1,500 ppm over the pool's start-up reading, and in a salt pool most of the number is the salt.

The specific mistakes

Testing CYA in a cold or hot sample. The stabilizer test is temperature sensitive. LaMotte says it reads best between 70°F and 80°F, and that cold water can read high and warm water low. A BioLab paper from 1998 says much the same: above 70°F the result can come out falsely low. Let the sample sit until it reaches room temperature.

Reading the CYA tube in poor light. Taylor's method is to add sample until the black dot at the bottom just disappears when viewed from the top. The BioLab paper says a reading taken in a poorly lit spot comes out higher than the real level. Read it outdoors in daylight or under good light.

Not diluting a high CYA sample. Taylor's tube reads 30 to 100 ppm. At 100 or above, Taylor says to mix one part sample with one part CYA-free water, tap or bottled, test, and multiply by 2.

Testing right after adding something. Taylor says to wait at least two filtration cycles after a treatment chemical before retesting. AquaChek says 24 to 48 hours.

Testing combined chlorine after MPS. Non-chlorine shock reacts with DPD reagent #3, so it reads as combined chlorine. PHTA says to test before adding it, or add it in the evening and test the next morning. Taylor sells an interference remover, its K-1520 kit or the K-2041 and K-2042 packs, for the same problem.

Trusting the salt panel. Hayward's cell works out its salt figure from the electrical current the cell draws, and its training guide says scale and debris in the cell throw the reading off. Jandy says water temperature affects its readout. All three makers say to check salt before adding any, and Hayward and Pentair say to use a separate test.

Write it down

Single readings tell you where you are. A log tells you what your pool does. AquaChek recommends keeping one to spot changes and recurring problems, and Taylor suggests a notebook or its app.

Date, free chlorine, pH, alkalinity, plus monthly calcium and CYA. A notes app is fine, or the test log, which keeps each test on your phone, charts it and turns the latest into a plan. After a month you'll know whether your pH climbs on its own, how fast you lose chlorine in a heatwave, and whether your fill water is hardening the pool over time.

That's the difference between reacting to your pool and running it.

Go deeperWhat to do with those numbersTarget ranges, the order to adjust in, and the doses that work.

Testing kit

Frequently asked questions

How often should I test my pool water?

It depends on whom you ask. CDC tells home pool owners to test chlorine and pH at least twice a day. Taylor's kit card says daily, with alkalinity weekly and calcium and stabilizer monthly. AquaChek says at least two or three times a week, and Hayward's and Pentair's salt cell manuals say weekly. AquaChek adds a test after a party, heavy rain, or animals in the pool.

Are pool test strips accurate?

Less accurate than a DPD drop kit, according to CDC, and CDC's pool code says color-match readings get coarser as the numbers rise. Strips have one advantage: LaMotte points out that high chlorine can bleach a DPD test clear but cannot bleach a strip. Keep the cap on tight, because AquaChek says moisture ruins unused strips.

What is the best pool test kit?

A drop-based FAS-DPD kit. You count drops until the pink turns clear rather than matching a color. Taylor's version reads 0.2 ppm per drop on a 25 mL sample, or 0.5 ppm per drop on a 10 mL sample up to 20 ppm. Taylor lists its K-2006 complete FAS-DPD kit from $142.71.

Where should I take a pool water sample from?

About 18 inches below the surface, which Taylor calls elbow depth, away from return lines and chemical feeders. CDC's pool code uses the same depth, because sunlight acts on the surface and most contaminants sit in the top 18 inches.

How long do pool test reagents last?

Go by the best-by date on each bottle. Taylor's instruction card says to replace reagents once a year, and its FAQ says to store them between 36°F and 85°F, out of direct sunlight and away from pool chemicals. Taylor also says a reagent that has changed color or grown undissolved particles should be thrown out.

Sources and further reading

Where this guide relied on standards, manufacturer documentation or published research rather than first-hand work.

Show the other 19 sources

Published September 5, 2026 · Last reviewed October 9, 2026. Spotted something out of date or wrong? Tell me and I will fix it — see the editorial policy.

About the author

Robert Henry

Pool service and repair, 15+ years

Over fifteen years in the pool business — service routes, equipment repair and warranty work, and the test counter.

  • 15+ years in the pool industry
  • Residential service routes
  • Equipment repair and warranty work
  • Pool retail and water testing