This is the pool that never closes, in the week the forecast does something unusual. Different problem from winterizing, because there is no time to blow lines and no intention of closing. You are getting through a few days.
The strategy is simple and the failure mode is specific.
Key takeaways
- Pentair and Hayward say to run the pump 24/7 until temperatures are back above freezing.
- Freeze protection is for short freezes. Jandy says it does not guarantee against long freezes or power outages.
- A power cut is the real emergency. Drain the equipment right away.
- Don't restore power while there is ice in the equipment. Hayward says to let it melt on its own.
- A pool heater is not freeze protection. Raypak, Hayward and Pentair all say so.
Moving water is the whole plan
Pentair's reason is the whole basis of it: moving water is less likely to freeze, so keep the equipment running and the pump circulating even in freezing temperatures. Without automation, Pentair says to run the equipment 24/7 until temperatures return to normal. Hayward says to keep the equipment running at all times until temperatures are above freezing.
Automation freeze protection helps, and it is not the same thing as running the pump:
- It starts at a set air temperature. Pentair's IntelliCenter switches on at 36°F. Hayward's OmniLogic and ProLogic default to 38°F, adjustable from 33 to 42°F. Jandy's AquaLink RS defaults to 38°F and switches off again within 2°F.
- It may not run continuously. IntelliCenter's freeze cycle time defaults to 5 minutes. Hayward's controls alternate the pool and spa valves every 30 minutes and stop the pump while the valves turn.
- The makers say what it is for. Jandy says its freeze protection is for short periods of freezing only, and does not guarantee against long freezes or power outages. Hayward's knowledge base says controller freeze protection is normally adequate where temperatures do not dip far below 32°F.
The pump's own freeze modes are narrower still. Pentair's IntelliFlo3 Thermal Mode senses the drive's internal temperature, and Hayward says its VS pumps' Low Temp mode is not intended to protect the plumbing or the pool. Both say not to rely on them.
So my habit for a hard freeze is to override the schedule and leave the pump running until the temperature is back up, rather than depend on a sensor and a cycle time. It costs little. ENERGY STAR's median in-ground variable-speed pump draws about 117 watts at its low test point, and 0.117 kW × 72 hours = 8.4 kWh. At EIA's July 2026 average residential price of 18.31 cents, that is about $1.55 for three days.
The pool itself is not what you are protecting. Kansas State University's rule of thumb for still water is about an inch of ice per 15 freezing degree-days once the first layer forms, and slower in moving water. Three days averaging 20°F works out to 12 × 3 ÷ 15 = 2.4 inches. The pipes and the equipment are what break, and they break because the water in them stopped moving.
Protecting a pool during a hard freeze
- 1
Pump on, continuous
2 minutesOverride the timer and leave it running until temperatures are back above freezing.
- 2
Check the air sensor
5 minutesFreeze protection works from the automation's air temperature sensor. Hayward says to make sure it is reading correctly and is not in direct sunlight, which would make the air look warmer than it is.
- 3
Leave running equipment uncovered
—Pentair says never to cover a pump motor that is running or expected to run, and Hayward and Jandy both say not to wrap a pump in plastic because it traps condensation. Hayward says a gas heater's vents must never be obstructed.
- 4
Know where the drain plugs are
10 minutesBefore you need them in the dark. Find the plugs on the pump strainer pot and volute, the filter, the heater and the multiport valve, and see how your salt cell drains. Put pliers and a flashlight where you will find them; Pentair says pliers help with a stiff plug.
When the power fails
This is the actual emergency. The moment circulation stops, everything above ground is standing water in the cold.
Pentair's outage steps:
- Turn off the breakers, so that when the power returns you can check everything before it starts.
- Remove the pump strainer pot lid and the filter lid, to relieve pressure and give expanding ice somewhere to go.
- Open as many valves as you can, including the air relief valve on top of the filter.
- Pull the plugs: the pump pot plug, the pump volute plug, the drain plugs by the heater and the plug at the multiport valve.
- Disconnect the motor from power if you can.
Hayward's list adds three things: pull the filter's drain plug, take the lids off any check valves, and remove the salt cell if you can or open it to drain. Pentair's pump guide suggests storing the plugs in the strainer basket, which is where you will look for them.
The lines in the ground cannot be drained without a blower, and Hayward's pump manual says to use only a low-pressure blower, below 5 psi, never compressed air. Protect what you can reach. Pentair adds a warning worth knowing in advance: a cracked pipe will not leak until it thaws.
Ice on the surface
Surface ice on a full pool is not where the makers' warnings concentrate, but it is not harmless either. Pentair says ice expanding at the surface can push against the tile and chip, break or loosen it, which is one more reason to keep the water moving.
Do not break it up. Bestway, writing about above-ground pools, says to remove ice carefully because its sharp edges can damage the liner, and Loop-Loc says not to try to remove ice from a cover for the same reason. Nothing I found recommends taking a tool to it.
Afterward, before you restart
Don't restore power while there is ice in the equipment. Hayward says to wait for it to melt on its own. If you drained the heater, Pentair says not to turn it on until water is circulating again.
Then:
- Refit every drain plug. On o-rings, Pentair says to use only PTFE or silicone lubricant, never petroleum; Hayward names Jack's 327, and Jandy says soapy water only on its VS FloPro's o-ring.
- Fill the pump housing and prime it. Hayward's rule: never run the pump without water.
- Start it and watch it. Pentair says to check the pump, pipes and lines for cracks, and to turn the pool off again if you find any.
- Walk the returns. A line that split in the ground shows up as reduced flow, air, or a level that keeps dropping, once it has thawed.
If the pool will not hold prime or the water level falls steadily over the following days, you have a split somewhere, and that is a leak-detection job rather than a chemistry one.
The things that make it worse
A short list, because each of these is a reasonable-sounding instinct that the makers' instructions rule out.
Turning the pump off to save it. The pump is not what is at risk, the plumbing is, and Pentair and Hayward both say to keep it running.
Breaking the ice on the surface. Covered above: sharp ice edges damage liners, by Bestway's account.
Running the heater to melt it. Raypak, Hayward and Pentair all say not to use a heater for freeze protection, and Pentair says running a heater without enough water flow can severely damage it. Pentair goes further and says to shut its heaters down and winterize them if the air is expected to drop below freezing; Raypak and Hayward allow a heater to run through a short cold spell only with the pump running continuously.
Draining the pool so it cannot freeze. Latham says a completely empty pool can crack or pop out of the ground from groundwater pressure, and its fiberglass warranty excludes damage from improper draining.
Wrapping the equipment in plastic. Pentair says not to wrap a pump motor in plastic or other airtight material, and Hayward and Jandy say plastic traps condensation that damages the pump.
If this happens most years
Then the honest answer is that you are in a closing climate rather than a year-round one. Hayward's knowledge base says controller freeze protection is normally adequate only where temperatures do not dip far below 32°F, and that otherwise the pool should be shut down for the winter. Pentair's freeze page goes further still, suggesting you consider a full closure if the forecast says 45°F or lower.
Closing the pool properly, with the lines blown out and plugged, costs an afternoon and removes the whole category of risk.
Go deeperThe permanent versionClearing and plugging every line, which is what makes a freeze a non-event.Frequently asked questions
Should I run my pool pump during a freeze?
Yes, around the clock until the temperature is back above freezing. Pentair says that without automation you should run the equipment 24/7, and Hayward says all pumps should run while temperatures are below freezing. It costs little: by my arithmetic from ENERGY STAR's figures, a variable-speed pump at a low speed uses about 8 kWh over 72 hours, about $1.55 at the July 2026 average US home electricity price.
What do I do if the power goes out during a freeze?
Drain the equipment right away. Pentair's list is to turn off the breakers, remove the pump and filter lids, and open as many valves as you can, including the filter's air relief. Then pull the pump pot plug, the pump volute plug, the drain plugs by the heater and the plug at the multiport valve. Hayward adds draining or removing the salt cell and taking the lids off check valves.
Is it bad if my pool freezes over?
The equipment and plumbing are where the makers' warnings concentrate, because water standing in them freezes and splits them. Surface ice is not harmless, though: Pentair says ice expanding at the surface can push against the tile and chip or loosen it, which is one more reason to keep the water moving.
Should I break the ice on my pool?
Nothing I found recommends breaking it up with a tool. Bestway, writing about above-ground pools, says to remove ice carefully because its sharp edges can damage the liner, and Loop-Loc says not to try to remove ice from a cover for the same reason. Keeping the pump running is the makers' answer to ice, not a hammer.
Can I use a pool heater to stop the pool freezing?
No. Raypak, Hayward and Pentair all say not to use a heater for freeze protection. Raypak and Hayward allow a heater to keep running through a short cold spell as long as the pump runs continuously, while Pentair says to shut it down and winterize it if the air is expected to drop below freezing. If the power fails, the heater stops too, and needs draining like everything else.



